5 Best Pizza Places in Bloomington, IL

December 26th, 2018 by

Hand Tossed Pepperoni Pizza

Whether you’re planning a big party or just looking for things to do in Bloomington, there is enough pizza in Bloomington, IL to eat at a new place every night for weeks. With so many restaurants in Bloomington, it can be tough to make a choice — we’re here to help. When you want something different than Domino’s or Pizza Hut, try one of our 5 favorite pizza places in Bloomington.

Tobin’s Pizza

Could we have a list of Bloomington-Normal pizzerias without Tobin’s on it? We’re starting off with them because a visit to Tobin’s Pizza is a 2-for-1: you can also order the famous Micheleo’s pizza from their menu. Both famous for their thin crusts, Micheleo’s is a bit thicker — a great choice for the pizza connoisseur who wants to taste the crust alongside the toppings and sauce. Both Tobin’s and Micheleo’s are available in a thick pan pizza as well. It’s tough to pick a favorite, but the Ozark BBQ Deluxe should probably be tried by all, and don’t forget the Tobin’s Family Buck Stretcher — order a 16-inch pizza and take home a 10-inch of the same kind for just $1.

Grady’s Pizza

Though they started as a small shack on Morrissey, Grady’s Pizza has grown substantially over the years to bring as much entertainment to your evening as their pizza does to your taste buds. Their pizza is made with a unique, sweet sauce that has made them famous in Central Illinois. Give it a try with sausage or pepperoni for a sweet/savory mix that you won’t find anywhere else. And after the food has settled, head over to their Family Fun Park for mini golf, go karts, and more.

Lucca Grill

A full-service Italian restaurant, Lucca Grill is a Bloomington institution that has served generations of families from its location on the corner of Market and East. If you’ve never had a Lucca pizza before, we think it’s best to start with the famous A La Baldini (savory sausage, pepperoni, ham, onions, mushrooms, green peppers and pepperoncini), but their thin crust, savory sauce, and long list of toppings means you can compile the pizza of your dreams with ease.

Flingers Pizza Pub

A long-time favorite of downtown Bloomington night life, we know quite a few locals who were disappointed when Flingers closed their doors. It’s why we’re so excited that Flinger’s Pizza Pub re-opened with their famous Cheese Bombs and Flinger Rolls alongside good old-fashioned pizzas and calzones. Now located at 1503 East Vernon, it’s almost like Flingers never closed. In addition to their near endless list of pizzas and appetizers, they also feature an extensive craft beer selection, including locals like White Oak and Triptych.

Monical’s Pizza

The only chain restaurant on our list, Monical’s is a midwestern favorite and offers a pizza that’s both familiar and unique. From their famous, triangular POINT pizza to traditional thin crust and deep dish, they cover all of their bases. Choose a simple sausage or spring for a specialty pie like their BBQ Chicken or Florentine. Don’t forget to try their famous Sweet and Tart dressing — on the salad or on the pizza!

Explore the Area

If you need to recover from a food coma after an amazing pizza experience, revive yourself at one of the best coffee shops in Bloomington. BMW of Bloomington is happy to help you with any local recommendations you may need, like things to do in Uptown Normal!

More From BMW of Bloomington

  • How Much Can a 2021 BMW X7 Tow?

      As befits the largest model in the BMW SAV® lineup, the BMW X7 not only offers a remarkably spacious interior, it also delivers dynamic performance and robust towing capabilities that will serve you well on your next adventure outside of Normal. How much can a BMW X7 tow? The 2021 BMW X7 towing capacity…

  • 2021 BMW X1 Interior Details

      The versatile BMW X1 is the smallest SAV® in the BMW X model lineup, but that doesn’t mean it won’t deliver big when it comes to luxury. With its generous passenger and cargo space, and wide array of premium features, the BMW X1 interior will elevate any drive in and around Normal. Learn all…

  • Introducing the 2022 BMW i4 & 2022 BMW iX

    The 2022 BMW i4 and 2022 BMW iX will soon be added to the new BMW inventory here at BMW of Bloomington. These highly anticipated models will give drivers from Normal to Decatur the opportunity to enjoy legendary BMW performance on a full electric platform. The new BMW i4 electric four-door coupe and BMW ix electric Sports…

Posted in Local Attractions